British eco-activists are asking: is disruption the best way to avert climate disaster? | Jack Shenker

As XR shifts away from radical action and the UK government restricts the right to protest, the climate movement is asking tough questionsOn a bright, chilly morning in January, seven women - some young, some older, all condemned as guilty by the state - gathered at Southwark crown court.The group had already been convicted of criminal damage following an Extinction Rebellion (XR) action in April 2021 that involved breaking windows at the headquarters of Barclays Bank: a financial institution responsible for more than ?4bn of fossil fuel financing during that year alone. "In case of climate emergency break glass", read stickers they stuck to the shattered panes. Now they were being sentenced. After a long preamble, the judge eventually handed down suspended terms, sparing the defendants jail for the time being. But he used his closing remarks to condemn their protest as a "stunt" that wouldn't help to solve the climate crisis. "You risk alienating those who you look to for support," he warned. Continue reading...